Are There Amish Millionaires? What the Research Shows
Yes, Amish millionaires exist, though no one publishes names. Donald Kraybill of Elizabethtown College says the phrase "Amish millionaire" is no longer an oxymoron. The wealth comes mostly from business ownership and farmland that has climbed in value. Amish businesses fail far less often than average, but church rules keep them small.
| By RichTactic Editorial Team
Quick Answer: Yes, Amish millionaires exist, mostly business owners and land-rich farmers. What research says on Amish business success, land values and where the money goes. This comprehensive guide (7 min read) covers verified strategies with real income data.
Yes, Amish millionaires exist, mostly business owners and land-rich farmers. What research says on Amish business success, land values and where the money goes.
Category: Communities | Read Time: 7 min read | Published: 2026-11-14
Tags: are there amish millionaires, amish millionaires, are amish rich, how wealthy are the amish, are there amish billionaires, where do amish keep their money, do amish keep their money in banks, do amish invest their money, where do the amish get their money, amish millionaire series, the amish millionaire series in order, wealthiest amish family
Key Takeaways
- Based on verified income data from 186 side hustle tactics and real-world case studies
- Income figures are estimates - individual results vary by market, effort, and skill level
- Most side hustles can be started with $0-$500 in startup capital
- Typical timeline to first income: 2 weeks to 3 months depending on the strategy
- The best approach combines a high-margin skill-based hustle with disciplined reinvestment
What You'll Learn
This in-depth guide covers everything you need to know about are there amish millionaires? what the research shows. Based on verified income data and real-world case studies from our database of 186 side hustle tactics.
The fact you looked up Amish millionaires says you have already noticed the contradiction: plain dress and horse-drawn buggies on the road, and on either side of it, farmland and workshops that plainly cost a great deal.
Yes, Amish millionaires exist, though nobody publishes a list. Donald Kraybill, senior fellow at Elizabethtown College's Young Center, said in 2010 that "the phrase 'Amish millionaire' is no longer an oxymoron." Wealth comes mostly from business ownership and from farmland that has risen sharply in value. Amish businesses fail far less often than average, but church rules keep them small and spending modest.
What does the research say about Amish wealth?
The research documents wealth in general terms and almost never names individuals. That is deliberate: the Amish value humility, and Erik Wesner changed every individual's name in his book on Amish business for that reason, as LancasterOnline's review noted.
What the scholars do say:
- Millionaires exist. Kraybill told Religion News Service that "the phrase 'Amish millionaire' is no longer an oxymoron", in a 2010 piece that also reported Amish firms landing contracts with companies such as Kmart and Ralph Lauren.
- Some businesses are large. The Young Center at Elizabethtown College says the annual sales of the larger Amish businesses may exceed five million dollars, though most have fewer than ten employees.
- Wealthy Amish are usually business owners. Wesner's answer to "are they rich?" is that some Amish earn a large income and may be quite wealthy, and that these are usually the business people. Farmers may hold very valuable land but have limited cash flow, and day labourers have limited income.
How successful are Amish businesses?
More successful than most. Kraybill, Steven Nolt and Erik Wesner studied Amish firms in eight states and found a success rate above 90 percent, "much higher than that of other American small businesses." The same 2011 paper counts some 10,000 Amish small businesses in North America.
Other figures from the same research group, reported at different times:
| Figure | Source and year |
|---|---|
| Fewer than 5 percent of Amish businesses fail, per a 2004 Goshen College study | New York Times, 2009 |
| 10 percent of Amish enterprises failed in their first five years, versus 50 percent of small businesses | Religion News Service, 2010 |
| Fewer than 10 percent of Amish startups fail in five years, versus 65 percent of North American businesses | LancasterOnline, 2016 |
The 2011 paper itself flags the limit: its qualitative methods "do not permit quantitative analysis or tracking the performance of businesses over an extended period of time." Treat the precise percentages as estimates; the direction is consistent across every report.
Kraybill gave the Times one reason failures are rare: "the church usually comes in and takes over failing businesses before they fail." In his 2016 talk he listed others, including apprenticeship from an early age, low overhead, dense trust networks, niche products and the positive associations of the word "Amish" with buyers.
Where did the money come from?
Mostly from the move off the farm. Kraybill calls the shift from farming to small business a "mini-industrial revolution" and told the Times in 2009 that more than half of Amish households now earn their primary income from small business, rising above 90 percent in some settlements. Furniture, construction, small manufacturing and food businesses are where the larger incomes show up.
Costs matter as much as revenue. Amish owners and their Amish employees can both be exempt from Social Security and Medicare taxes when each holds an approved IRS Form 4029; the exemption does not touch income tax. Kraybill lists payroll costs among his twelve success factors, but Amish owners told LancasterOnline the effect is often exaggerated, because they pay into Amish Aid, the community's mutual aid fund, and pay full payroll taxes for any non-Amish staff.
Are most Amish rich?
No. Wealth is concentrated among business owners and long-held farms. Wesner notes that day labourers, a common Amish occupation, have limited income, and that farmers may be land-rich with little cash. Household size also stretches income: the Young Center's FAQ says over half the population in most communities are children and unbaptized teens.
Views differ on the low end. The Amish Heritage Foundation, a secular advocacy group founded by Torah Bontrager, states on its site that average Amish income is below the federal poverty level; the page does not cite a dataset. The Young Center cautions that the diversity among Amish affiliations makes it "risky to generalize about 'the' Amish," and the US Census does not ask about religion, so no official Amish income figure exists.
Why don't you see the money?
Because the rules on spending are the same for a millionaire as for a labourer. Dress, buggies, house furnishings and technology are set by the church district, not by income. Wesner writes that it is harder to tell who the Amish millionaires are because status symbols are less visible, at least to outsiders.
Size limits apply too. Wesner told Religion News Service that bishops will break up businesses that grow too large: "You don't see 500-employee Amish companies with Amish CEOs kicking their feet up on a mahogany desk." Kraybill's list of success factors includes the reverse view, credited to an Amish man: "Bigness spoils everything."
Where the money goes instead, per Wesner: property, horses, the business itself, and in more progressive communities, mutual funds and stocks. Amish adults usually have checking accounts, and some use credit cards.
Land: the quiet source of Amish wealth
For many Amish families the largest asset is land, and in Lancaster County its value has climbed fast. The Census of Agriculture put average county farmland at $21,633 an acre in 2022, and local experts told LancasterOnline in 2024 that current prices had reached $40,000 to $50,000 an acre. The president of the Lancaster Farmland Trust gave a similar range in 2025, adding that some individual sales exceed $55,000 an acre.
Simple arithmetic shows what that means. At $40,000 an acre, a 100-acre farm is worth $4 million on paper. A family that bought decades ago at a fraction of that, and owes little on it, can be worth millions without ever having a large cash income. That is the "land-rich, cash-limited" farmer Wesner describes.
The Amish hold a large share of that land. A 1999 Elizabethtown College survey, comparing 1996 tax records with church rolls, found Amish owned 38.2 percent of Lancaster County farms of 25 acres or more, about 103,000 acres. With Mennonites added, Old Order groups owned 57 percent. The Trust says 85 percent of the farms it preserves belong to Amish or Mennonite farmers.
Land prices are also why many young families move. High prices push the next generation into other counties and states, where the same money buys a working farm.
Documented Amish business stories
Because names are rarely published, the documented cases are the ones owners chose to share with reporters.
- Bentwood Solutions, Millersburg, Ohio. Atlee Kaufman, who is Amish, started bending buggy shafts in a small building beside his house four decades ago. He expanded into table and chair parts, did well enough to sell off the buggy shaft division, and grew the company to about 40 people. His sons and son-in-law now run it.
- Emma's Gourmet Popcorn, near New Holland, Pennsylvania. An Amish-owned snack business that started with one woman popping corn by hand and now sells wholesale and ships nationally through its website, which Kraybill cites as an example of Amish firms contracting for technology they do not own.
- Amish Naturals, Holmesville, Ohio. Co-founded by Kenny Troyer, an Old Order Amish man, with a non-Amish partner to sell pasta, granola and sauces from Amish recipes, as the Times reported in 2009.
None of these reports gives a sale price or a net worth, and the page does not guess at one.
Where do Amish keep their money?
Mostly in local banks, in land and in their own businesses. NPR reported in 2008 that one Lancaster banker carried about $100 million in agricultural loans, 95 percent of them to Amish clients, and that he had never lost money on an Amish deal. The Bank of Bird-in-Hand, whose clientele is mostly Plain, had not recorded a single 30-day loan delinquency between its December 2013 opening and 2016, its president told LancasterOnline.
Savings also flow into the community. Amish mutual aid covers large medical bills and disaster losses, and benefit auctions raise money when costs exceed what a district can handle. In one documented case from Ira Wagler's memoir, cited in the American Studies Journal, voluntary contributions from Amish readers of the magazine Family Life paid $80,000 in medical expenses for his brother, who was paralyzed in an accident in 1982.
Savings can also be lost. In 2025 the Philadelphia Inquirer reported that Amish, Mennonite and other investors in Lancaster County had put hundreds of millions of dollars into a non-Amish local businessman's ATM company that defaulted, among about 2,700 investors. The rank-and-file investors had not sued, and a Lancaster native quoted in the piece explained that Amish teaching discourages suing fellow believers.
Are there Amish billionaires?
There is no documented case. The scholarship on Amish business describes small and mid-sized firms that bishops keep from growing very large, and land holdings that can reach millions per family, but nothing on the scale of a billion dollars.
The "Amish Millionaire" books
If you were looking for the novels, the "Amish Millionaire" series is fiction by Wanda E. Brunstetter and her daughter-in-law Jean Brunstetter. It follows Joel Byler, who left his Amish roots at eighteen, as he returns to Holmes County, Ohio, to ask his wealthy, eccentric Amish father for money again. The author's site lists the six parts in order: The English Son, The Stubborn Father, The Betrayed Fiancee, The Missing Will, The Divided Family and The Selfless Act, also sold together as one collection. The setting is real: the Holmes County and Lancaster County areas are older Amish settlements, each with more than 300 church districts.
Building wealth within the Ordnung
The documented pattern is slow and local: learn a trade young, start small near home, keep overhead low, buy land, and lend and borrow within a network that knows your family. Before any expansion (more employees, a phone in the shop, a website run by a partner, new machinery), check with your bishop and the Ordnung, because the size and technology rules apply to the successful shop as much as the new one.
The day-to-day picture of Amish work is on how the Amish make money, women's businesses are covered on how Amish women make money, and selling through partners is on how Old Order communities sell online. Other communities are compared in how close-knit communities make money.
Frequently asked questions
Are there Amish millionaires?
Yes. Donald Kraybill of Elizabethtown College's Young Center said in 2010 that "the phrase 'Amish millionaire' is no longer an oxymoron." Most are business owners or families holding farmland bought long ago in places like Lancaster County, where farmland sold for $40,000 to $50,000 an acre by 2024. Researchers do not publish names, in keeping with the Amish value of humility.
Are Amish rich?
Some are, most are not. Erik Wesner of Amish America writes that wealthy Amish are usually business owners, that farmers may be land-rich with limited cash flow, and that day labourers have limited income. Families are large, and over half the population in most communities are children, so one household income has to cover many people.
Where do Amish keep their money?
In local banks, in land and in their own businesses. Amish adults usually have checking accounts, and they borrow from local banks mainly to buy farms. More progressive communities also invest in mutual funds and stocks. Savings also go to mutual aid, which covers large medical bills and disaster losses for church members.
Are there Amish billionaires?
There is no documented case. Research on Amish business describes small and mid-sized firms, with the larger ones exceeding $5 million in annual sales according to the Young Center. Bishops discourage businesses from growing very large, and land holdings, though valuable, are counted in millions per family rather than billions.
Who wrote the Amish Millionaire series?
Wanda E. Brunstetter and her daughter-in-law Jean Brunstetter. The six-part fiction serial is set in Holmes County, Ohio, and follows Joel Byler, who left the Amish at eighteen and returns to ask his wealthy father for money. In order: The English Son, The Stubborn Father, The Betrayed Fiancee, The Missing Will, The Divided Family and The Selfless Act.
Do Amish keep their money in banks?
Yes. Amish adults typically have checking accounts and pay by cash or check, and they borrow from local banks mainly to buy farms. A Lancaster banker told NPR in 2008 that 95 percent of his roughly $100 million farm loan book was Amish. The Bank of Bird-in-Hand, mostly serving Plain customers, reported no 30-day loan delinquency from its 2013 opening to 2016.
Related Guides
- How to Get Rich: 15 Strategies With Real Data
- Best Side Hustle Ideas 2026: 30 Ranked
- Make Money From Home: 25 Proven Methods
Explore Related Tactics
Dive deeper into the specific strategies mentioned in this article:
- Ultimate Guide to AI Automation Agency
- Ultimate Guide to UGC Creator
- Ultimate Guide to Freelance Writing
- Ultimate Guide to Dropshipping 2.0
Free Tools
Browse by Category
- AI & Automation Side Hustles
- E-commerce Side Hustles
- Freelancing Side Hustles
- Content Creation Side Hustles
Read the full article at https://richtactic.com/blog/are-there-amish-millionaires