How Do Old Order Communities Sell Online Without Internet?

Most Old Order sellers reach online buyers through someone else: an English retailer or wholesaler, or a family member who runs the website or Etsy shop, while the maker takes orders by phone shanty voicemail, fax or mail. Produce auctions, market stands and consignment shops carry the rest, within church rules.

| By RichTactic Editorial Team

Quick Answer: How Amish and Old Order sellers reach online buyers: English retailers, produce auctions, phone shanty orders and Etsy shops run by family, within church rules. This comprehensive guide (7 min read) covers verified strategies with real income data.

How Amish and Old Order sellers reach online buyers: English retailers, produce auctions, phone shanty orders and Etsy shops run by family, within church rules.

Category: Communities | Read Time: 7 min read | Published: 2026-11-14

Tags: do amish sell online, do amish sell products online, do amish sell things online, do amish have websites, do amish use internet, can amish have cell phones, amish online store, etsy amish furniture, amish produce auction, what do amish markets sell, old order mennonite selling, amish phone shanty

Key Takeaways

  • Based on verified income data from 186 side hustle tactics and real-world case studies
  • Income figures are estimates - individual results vary by market, effort, and skill level
  • Most side hustles can be started with $0-$500 in startup capital
  • Typical timeline to first income: 2 weeks to 3 months depending on the strategy
  • The best approach combines a high-margin skill-based hustle with disciplined reinvestment

What You'll Learn

This in-depth guide covers everything you need to know about how do old order communities sell online without internet?. Based on verified income data and real-world case studies from our database of 186 side hustle tactics.

Good call looking at how Plain businesses reach distant buyers before anyone sets up a shop page. The routes that work all start from what your church allows, and those rules differ from district to district.

Most Old Order sellers reach online buyers through someone else: an English retailer or wholesaler, or a family member or partner who runs the website or marketplace listing, while the maker takes orders by phone shanty voicemail, fax or mail. Produce auctions, city market stands and consignment shops carry the rest. Check with your bishop and the Ordnung before you start.

What the rules usually allow

The Young Center at Elizabethtown College describes the general pattern: televisions, radios and personal computers are rejected outright, while other technology is used selectively or modified, and battery power can run calculators, cash registers, copy machines and typewriters in some settlements.

Kraybill explains the distinction that makes online selling possible: the culture separates using technology from owning it. That is why it is acceptable for an Amish business such as Emma's Gourmet Popcorn to contract with a website developer, or for carpenters to ride to job sites with hired drivers.

Phones follow the same logic. A guest writer on Amish America describes the phone shanties in his part of northern Indiana: a shared phone kept in a small building outside the house, where the shanties have answering machines, callers dial an extension and leave a message, and the family calls back later. Some bishops now allow phones in places of business. One Amish business owner he deals with has a phone and a fax in his office, and software on the English side converts emails to faxes and faxes back to emails.

Individual choices vary too. In Karen Johnson-Weiner's research, a Lancaster flower shop owner had a phone in her shop and advertised on the Intercourse, Pennsylvania, website but would not use the internet herself. An herb shop owner declined it entirely: "Why start on something the church wants to stay away from?"

The routes, compared

RouteWho touches the internetWhat you give upBest for
Wholesale to an English retailerThe retailerRetail margin, your own customer listFurniture, structures, larger items
Produce auctionNobodyPrice control; you take the day's bidProduce, flowers, plants
City market standNobodyThree long days a week, driver costsFood, baked goods, crafts
Consignment or shop salesThe shop, if it sells onlineA share of each saleQuilts, crafts
Phone, fax and mail ordersNobody, or a partner's email-to-fax serviceSpeedRepeat customers, catalogs, parts
Etsy or a website run by a family member or partnerThe family member or partnerSome control; Etsy feesHandmade goods you make yourself

Wholesale through English retailers

This is how most Amish furniture reaches buyers online. The New York Times reported that one Ohio retailer, Amish Originals Furniture Company, buys from 75 Amish craftsmen in northern Ohio, and that many Amish businesses have partnered with non-Amish entrepreneurs to sell to the public. DutchCrafters, an online retailer founded in 2003, describes itself as selling made-to-order furniture built by woodworkers it has worked with for years.

The retailer handles the website, photography, payment, customer service and delivery. You build to order. The cost is the retail margin and the fact that the customer relationship belongs to the retailer.

In Holmes County, Ohio, many shops sit one step further back. About 50 members of the county's Hardwood Furniture Guild are "sub shops" making one component for larger makers, so a single table may pass through four shops before a retailer sells it.

Produce auctions

A produce auction needs no internet, no advertising and no customer list. You bring the crop and buyers bid. Penn State Extension counts sixteen produce auctions in Pennsylvania, mostly grower-owned, serving about 5,000 growers and generating more than $50 million a year for their vendors.

The Leola Produce Auction in Lancaster County, founded in 1985, is owned by groups of farmers, runs from March to November, and draws garden centres, farm markets, restaurants and grocers from across the Mid-Atlantic. Its buyer rules require payment in full on the day of sale, by cash or approved check, unless the auction approves credit, which protects the seller.

Prices swing with supply. The auction's report for August 4, 2026, printed in Lancaster Farming, showed sweet corn at $2.50 to $7.00 a dozen and red tomatoes at $32.00 to $75.00 a box. Penn State's study of auction data found the biggest gains came from timing: one grower who planted earlier and skipped the July and August glut averaged $51.18 a unit for early tomatoes, against $21.77 for the same grower's peak-season tomatoes the previous year.

In Ohio, the Kidron Auction in Kidron has served Ohio agriculture for over 100 years, with dairy cattle and other livestock sold every Thursday.

Spring mud sales are a different thing. Lancaster County's mud sales are fundraisers for volunteer fire companies, with quilts, furniture, livestock and produce up for bid, and some are listed as consignment sales where sellers bring their own goods.

City market stands

Lancaster County Amish run food stands in markets across the Mid-Atlantic, and Kraybill has counted more than 50 Amish markets between Annapolis and New York City. A stand reaches city customers with no website at all. The economics, commutes and examples are on how the Amish make money.

Consignment and local shops

Quilts and crafts often reach online buyers through a shop that does the selling. The Quilt Shop at Miller's in Lancaster County, for example, has a 3,500-square-foot showroom and an online store of quilts hand-stitched by Lancaster County Amish and Mennonite artisans, with 192 items listed in November 2026. The maker sews; the shop photographs, prices, ships and takes card payments.

Before you hand over work, ask whether the shop buys outright or sells on consignment, what share you keep, when you are paid, who carries the loss if an item is damaged or stolen, and whether the shop will list your work online under your name or only as "Amish-made." Get the answers on paper.

Phone, fax and mail orders

For repeat customers and trade buyers, the phone shanty and a printed price list still work. A practical setup:

  • A voicemail extension that you check at set times, and a greeting that says when you return calls, so customers do not assume you are ignoring them.
  • A printed price list or catalog mailed or handed to customers, with the shanty number and a mailing address for orders.
  • Fax, where your bishop allows it, for written orders and confirmations. A customer or partner on the English side can use an email-to-fax service, as in the Amish America example above.
  • Payment by check on pickup or before shipping, which keeps you out of card processing.

Etsy or a website run by a family member or partner

This is where the rules get specific, and they are Etsy's rules as much as the church's.

Etsy's Creativity Standards say every item must be made, designed, handpicked or sourced by the seller. "Made by a seller" means physical items made by the seller by hand or with personal or computerized tools, such as "a wooden chair built by hand with a power saw and sander." Reselling and dropshipping are not allowed outside narrow exceptions.

That matters for a common plan: an English relative opens a shop and lists an Amish neighbour's chairs. Under Etsy's Seller Policy, each listing must accurately say how the item was made, by whom and where it ships from, and the shop's About section must describe every shop member involved in making the items or running the business. Etsy's help centre is explicit that you and your team are part of your shop, not production partners, and that production partners apply only to items made from the seller's own designs. Etsy says sourcing ready-made products from businesses that do not qualify as production partners violates its reselling policy.

The version most consistent with these rules is a shop that belongs to the maker's household or business, with the family member who runs the account listed as a shop member, and the maker named as the one who makes the items. Read Etsy's Seller Policy together before anything is listed, because the account holder is responsible for it.

Fees, as of Etsy's policy updated October 2026: a $0.20 listing fee per item, a 6.5 percent transaction fee on the item price plus shipping, payment processing fees, and an Offsite Ads fee of 15 percent on orders that come through Etsy's outside advertising (12 percent once a shop passes $10,000 in yearly sales; smaller shops can opt out). Etsy issues 1099-K forms to qualifying US sellers, so the income must be reported. Our Etsy guide covers listing and pricing.

A standalone website works the same way, minus Etsy's rules: the partner owns the technology, the maker owns the business. Emma's Gourmet Popcorn is the documented example. Its owner told Johnson-Weiner that she started "packaging for wholesale, gift items, and the website," and the line now ships nationally. She also said she worries about how far the church will accept it.

Selling food online

Home-made food has its own rules on top of the church's. In Pennsylvania, a Limited Food Establishment registration ($35 a year) covers shelf-stable foods made in a home kitchen and includes internet sales direct from the production site. Selling across state lines may also need FDA registration, and wholesale to other food businesses needs a different license. The home bakery guide covers pricing and labels.

Setting terms with an English partner

Most problems in these partnerships come from what was never written down. Before the first order, agree on:

  • Who owns the customer list and the shop or website account if the partnership ends.
  • How prices are set and who can change them.
  • When the maker gets paid: on order, on shipment, or after the platform pays out.
  • Who handles returns and complaints, and who pays for damaged shipments.
  • What the listing says about the maker. Whatever you agree, Etsy requires it to be accurate.
  • What the church allows: photos of the maker or the shop, use of the maker's name, phone or fax at the shop. Settle this with your bishop first.

Hired drivers are part of the arrangement for many sellers. The Young Center notes that many Amish groups permit members to hire "taxis" driven by local non-Amish people for business and long-distance trips, which is how goods reach markets, shippers and retailers.

Mennonite and other Plain sellers use many of the same routes; see how Mennonites make money and how Low German Mennonites make money. Women's home businesses are on how Amish women make money, and the non-church version of farm-and-craft selling is on how homesteaders make money. Other communities are compared in how close-knit communities make money.

Frequently asked questions

Do Amish sell online?

Many Amish products are sold online, but usually not by the Amish maker personally. English retailers and wholesalers, or a family member or partner, run the website or marketplace shop while the maker builds to order and takes calls by phone shanty or shop phone. Kraybill explains that Amish culture separates using technology from owning it, which is why an Amish firm can hire a web developer.

Do Amish have websites?

Some Amish businesses do, built and run by contracted developers or partners. Emma's Gourmet Popcorn, an Amish-owned business near New Holland, Pennsylvania, offers online ordering and ships nationally. Other Amish owners decline websites and the internet entirely. Whether a website is acceptable is decided by each church district, so the answer varies between neighbouring communities.

Can Amish have cell phones?

It depends on the church district. Some communities keep a shared phone in a shanty outside the house, often with an answering machine, and some bishops now allow phones in places of business. Unbaptized youth in some communities carry smartphones. Rules are set locally, so practice in one settlement may differ from the next one down the road.

Can you sell Amish furniture on Etsy?

Only under Etsy's rules. Items listed as made by a seller must be made by the seller or a shop member, and every listing must say how the item was made, by whom and where it ships from. Reselling furniture bought from someone else's business is not allowed. A shop belonging to the maker, run by a family member listed as a shop member, fits the rules best.

What do Amish markets sell?

Amish produce auctions sell fresh produce, flowers and plants in wholesale lots to farm markets, garden centres, restaurants and grocers. Market stands run by Lancaster County Amish in Mid-Atlantic city markets sell baked goods, deli meats and other foods, and some markets include furniture stores. Spring mud sales, which raise money for volunteer fire companies, auction quilts, furniture, livestock and produce.

How do Amish take orders without internet?

By phone shanty voicemail, shop phones where the bishop allows them, fax, mail and in person. A guest writer on Amish America describes phone shanties with answering machines where callers dial an extension and leave a message, and an Amish business owner whose faxes reach customers as emails through software on the customer's side.

Related Guides

Explore Related Tactics

Dive deeper into the specific strategies mentioned in this article:

Free Tools

Browse by Category

Read the full article at https://richtactic.com/blog/how-do-old-order-communities-sell-online