The Broken Rung: Meaning, Data and Entry-Level Jobs Now
The broken rung is the first step on the career ladder failing. McKinsey and LeanIn.Org coined it in 2019 when 72 women were promoted to manager for every 100 men. It now also describes AI thinning entry-level work: Stanford finds employment of 22 to 25 year-olds in AI-exposed jobs 19% below its expected path.
| By RichTactic Editorial Team
Quick Answer: What the broken rung means, from McKinsey's 2019 finding on women's promotions to AI thinning entry-level jobs, with Stanford, NY Fed and hiring data. This comprehensive guide (4 min read) covers verified strategies with real income data.
What the broken rung means, from McKinsey's 2019 finding on women's promotions to AI thinning entry-level jobs, with Stanford, NY Fed and hiring data.
Category: Economy | Read Time: 4 min read | Published: 2026-11-15
Tags: broken rung, broken rung meaning, broken rung mckinsey, broken rung theory, broken rung economy, entry level jobs ai, bottom rung of the career ladder, why are entry level jobs disappearing
Key Takeaways
- Based on verified income data from 186 side hustle tactics and real-world case studies
- Income figures are estimates - individual results vary by market, effort, and skill level
- Most side hustles can be started with $0-$500 in startup capital
- Typical timeline to first income: 2 weeks to 3 months depending on the strategy
- The best approach combines a high-margin skill-based hustle with disciplined reinvestment
What You'll Learn
This in-depth guide covers everything you need to know about broken rung: meaning, data and entry-level jobs now. Based on verified income data and real-world case studies from our database of 186 side hustle tactics.
Plenty of people find the phrase "broken rung" after months of applying for junior roles that never seem to open. This page is for graduates and early-career workers who want the research behind it, and a way onto the ladder that does not wait for an employer to post the first step.
The broken rung is the first step on the career ladder that fails. McKinsey and LeanIn.Org coined it in 2019 for women: for every 100 men promoted to manager, only 72 women were. Since 2025 it also describes entry-level jobs thinning out as employers use AI for junior work. Stanford researchers estimate employment for 22 to 25 year-olds in AI-exposed jobs is 19% below its expected path.
Where the term comes from
The phrase comes from Women in the Workplace 2019, the annual study by McKinsey & Company and LeanIn.Org, which covered 329 companies and more than 68,500 employees. HR Dive reported the headline finding: for every 100 men promoted and hired to manager, only 72 women are. The authors put the barrier at the first promotion, well below the glass ceiling, and wrote: "Fixing this 'broken rung' is the key to achieving parity." LeanIn's report archive still frames the 2019 edition around the need to focus earlier in the pipeline to fix the broken rung.
The gap has narrowed since. LeanIn's 2025 report says that for every 100 men promoted to manager last year, only 93 women were promoted.
The second meaning: AI and the bottom of the ladder
From 2025 the same image started to describe something else: the junior job itself going missing. LinkedIn's chief economic opportunity officer, Aneesh Raman, warned in a New York Times essay, as Axios summarised it, that AI was breaking "the bottom rungs of the career ladder." In the same Axios piece, Anthropic chief executive Dario Amodei said AI could wipe out half of all entry-level white-collar jobs and push unemployment to 10-20% within one to five years. That is a forecast from someone who sells AI, so weigh it as one.
By late 2025 the term was in ordinary use. A CNBC report on young workers quoted Alison Lands of Jobs for the Future saying a good early job will help you leapfrog that broken rung on the career ladder.
What the data shows
| Measure | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Employment of 22-25 year-olds in AI-exposed occupations vs expected path | 19% below | Stanford Digital Economy Lab, August 2026 |
| US entry-level job postings, January 2023 to June 2025 | Down 35% | Revelio Labs, via CNBC |
| New graduates as a share of Big Tech hires | 7% | SignalFire, 2025 |
| Unemployment, recent graduates aged 22-27 vs all workers | 5.2% vs 4.0% (September 2026) | New York Fed |
| Same comparison in January 1990 | 3.4% vs 5.1% | New York Fed |
The strongest evidence is Stanford's "Canaries in the Coal Mine?" by Erik Brynjolfsson, Bharat Chandar and Ruyu Chen, built on payroll records. Its August 2026 revision finds that employment of young workers (ages 22-25) in AI-exposed occupations now stands 19% below where it would be had it kept pace. Earlier versions put the gap at 13% on July 2025 data and 16% on September 2025 data. The decline works mainly through employers hiring fewer young people, not through firing existing staff. The authors describe these as early, descriptive indicators rather than proof that AI caused the drop.
Job ads point the same way. CNBC cited Revelio Labs data showing postings for entry-level jobs in the US plunged 35% from January 2023 to June 2025. In tech, SignalFire's talent report found new graduates account for just 7% of Big Tech hires, with new hires down over 50% from 2019.
The New York Fed's data shows how unusual this is. For most of its record, new graduates were less likely to be unemployed than the average worker. In January 1990, recent graduates had a 3.4% unemployment rate against 5.1% for all workers. In September 2026 it was 5.2% for recent graduates, against 4.0% for everyone.
Why a missing first rung matters more than a layoff
A layoff hurts one person once. A missing entry-level job changes a whole cohort's path, because the first job is where people learn the work, build a record and get the references that lead to the second job. If firms hire fewer juniors and ask seniors to supervise AI tools instead, the experience that used to be paid for by the employer has to be bought some other way.
Pay builds on itself, too. The first salary sets the base that later raises are calculated from, so a slow start costs more than the lost months.
Getting onto the ladder without the first rung
None of these require an employer to post a junior job.
Get paid for output before anyone hires you for a title. Small businesses still need bookkeeping, websites, short video edits and customer replies, and they will pay a freelancer by the job. A track record of paid projects does what the first job used to do. The hourly rate calculator shows what to charge to match a salary.
Pick work AI is pushing up rather than out. Some skills grew in demand because of AI: setting up automations, evaluating model output and installing tools for businesses that do not know how. The guide to AI automation agencies covers one route, and AI-proof jobs lists careers with the most protection.
Buy a credential only when it pays back. A short certification can stand in for the experience a junior role used to give. The credential ROI calculator shows when a course pays for itself.
Treat the first job as one income, not the whole plan. If you land a role, a side income built alongside it is insurance against the next round of cuts. AI layoffs shows which companies have already tied cuts to AI.
For the wider picture, why it is so hard to get ahead now compares housing, pay and pensions then and now. Many of the listings you are applying to may not be real hires at all, which the ghost jobs page measures. The K-shaped economy shows who gains while entry-level workers wait.
Frequently asked questions
What is the broken rung?
The first step on the career ladder failing. McKinsey and LeanIn.Org used it in 2019 for women's first promotion to manager, where 72 women were promoted for every 100 men. Since 2025 it also describes entry-level jobs thinning out as employers use AI for junior work.
Who coined the broken rung?
It comes from Women in the Workplace 2019, the study by McKinsey & Company and LeanIn.Org covering 329 companies. The authors called fixing it the route to parity. By 2025, 93 women were promoted to manager for every 100 men.
Is AI taking entry-level jobs?
The early evidence points that way. Stanford researchers found employment of 22 to 25 year-olds in AI-exposed jobs is 19% below its expected path, mainly through less hiring. The authors call this descriptive evidence, not proof that AI caused it.
How do you get a career started without an entry-level job?
Get paid for output before anyone hires you for a title: freelance projects for small businesses, AI setup work, or a short credential that pays back quickly. A record of paid work does what the first job used to do.
Sources & References
Primary sources for the figures on this page. Where a number is not covered below, it is an estimate rather than a measurement and is labelled as such in the text.
- Canaries in the Coal Mine? - Stanford Digital Economy Lab
Employment of 22-25 year-olds in AI-exposed jobs 19% below its expected path - Women in the Workplace - LeanIn.Org and McKinsey
The 2019 broken rung finding and the 2025 figure of 93 women per 100 men - The Labor Market for Recent College Graduates - Federal Reserve Bank of New York
Unemployment and underemployment of graduates aged 22-27, 1990 to 2026 - State of Talent Report 2025 - SignalFire
New graduates are 7% of Big Tech hires
Further reading: Women's biggest workplace obstacle is much earlier in the pipeline · Why AI may kill career advancement for many young workers · AI jobs danger: white-collar unemployment
Related Guides
- How to Get Rich: 15 Strategies With Real Data
- Best Side Hustle Ideas 2026: 30 Ranked
- Make Money From Home: 25 Proven Methods
Explore Related Tactics
Dive deeper into the specific strategies mentioned in this article:
- Ultimate Guide to AI Automation Agency
- Ultimate Guide to UGC Creator
- Ultimate Guide to Freelance Writing
- Ultimate Guide to Dropshipping 2.0
Free Tools
Browse by Category
- AI & Automation Side Hustles
- E-commerce Side Hustles
- Freelancing Side Hustles
- Content Creation Side Hustles
Read the full article at https://richtactic.com/blog/broken-rung