Ghost Jobs: How Many Listings Are Fake and How to Spot One
Ghost jobs are listings for roles a company is not actively filling. No official count exists, but Greenhouse classifies 18-22% of jobs on its platform each quarter as ghost jobs, and 40% of companies told Resume Builder they posted a fake listing in 2024. Ontario now requires postings to say whether a vacancy exists.
| By RichTactic Editorial Team
Quick Answer: What ghost jobs are, how many listings are fake (Greenhouse, Resume Builder and Clarify data), the new laws in Ontario and New York, and how to spot one. This comprehensive guide (4 min read) covers verified strategies with real income data.
What ghost jobs are, how many listings are fake (Greenhouse, Resume Builder and Clarify data), the new laws in Ontario and New York, and how to spot one.
Category: Economy | Read Time: 4 min read | Published: 2026-11-15
Tags: ghost jobs, ghost jobs meaning, what are ghost jobs, ghost job postings, ghost jobs percentage, ghost jobs illegal, ghost jobs law, how to spot a ghost job, fake job listings
Key Takeaways
- Based on verified income data from 186 side hustle tactics and real-world case studies
- Income figures are estimates - individual results vary by market, effort, and skill level
- Most side hustles can be started with $0-$500 in startup capital
- Typical timeline to first income: 2 weeks to 3 months depending on the strategy
- The best approach combines a high-margin skill-based hustle with disciplined reinvestment
What You'll Learn
This in-depth guide covers everything you need to know about ghost jobs: how many listings are fake and how to spot one. Based on verified income data and real-world case studies from our database of 186 side hustle tactics.
Whoever ends up searching "ghost jobs" has usually applied to a listing that sat open for months and never heard a word back. This page is for job seekers who want to know how common fake listings are, how to spot one, and how to stop waiting on them.
Ghost jobs are listings for roles a company is not actively filling: the job does not exist, or the employer has no plan to hire soon. No official count exists, but Greenhouse classifies 18-22% of the jobs posted on its platform in a typical quarter as ghost jobs, and in a 2024 Resume Builder survey 40% of companies said they had posted a fake listing that year. Ontario now requires employers to say whether a vacancy exists.
What counts as a ghost job
The Congressional Research Service defines them as online job postings for positions that do not exist, or that employers are not planning to fill immediately. Nobody is credited with coining the term. CRS found media reports of the practice from as early as 2003.
A listing can stay up after the role is filled, gather resumes for a role that may open later, or make a company look like it is growing. From the applicant's side they look the same as real openings.
How many listings are fake
| Source | Finding | Caveat |
|---|---|---|
| Greenhouse (hiring software), 2024 | 18-22% of jobs posted on its platform each quarter are ghost jobs | One platform's own classification |
| Greenhouse, second quarter of 2026, via the Wall Street Journal | About 19% of jobs on digital job boards | Same method |
| Resume Builder survey, 2024 | 40% of companies posted a fake listing that year; 3 in 10 had one live | Only firms that had posted one took the full survey |
| Clarify Capital survey of 1,045 managers, 2022 | 68% had postings open more than 30 days; 43% said they were not actively trying to fill positions | Self-reported |
Greenhouse reports that in any given quarter, 18-22% of the jobs posted on the Greenhouse platform are classified as ghost jobs. The Wall Street Journal, in a report republished by the University of Wisconsin's La Follette School, cited Greenhouse data putting the share at about 19% in the second quarter of 2026, and reported that Texas's attorney general had opened an investigation into LinkedIn.
Resume Builder found that 40% of companies posted a fake job listing this year, and that 7 in 10 of the hiring managers it surveyed thought posting fake jobs was morally acceptable. Clarify Capital found that 68% of managers had job postings active for more than 30 days.
Treat these as a range rather than a count. CRS points out that there are no official statistics, and that the firms running these surveys sell hiring-related services, which makes the quality of their estimates hard to judge.
Why the official numbers miss them
The government's job openings survey, JOLTS, counted 7.5 million openings in September 2026 against 5.4 million hires. It is tempting to call the difference ghost jobs. It is not: JOLTS only counts a position as open if work could start within 30 days and the employer is actively recruiting outside the company, so CRS says those openings are unlikely to be ghost jobs. The ghost listings live on job boards, outside that survey.
The laws coming in
Ontario went first. Since 1 January 2026, employers with 25 or more staff must include in each public job posting a statement disclosing whether a vacancy exists or not, under the Working for Workers Five Act, 2024. They must also tell interviewed candidates whether they got the job within 45 days.
New York's bill S8877 has passed the Senate and Assembly. It would make employers with 100 or more staff label postings that are not for a current vacancy, with a $2,500 fine. The Wall Street Journal reported in August that it was awaiting the governor's review.
Other states. Forbes counted bills in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, New York, California and Kentucky. At federal level, an advocates' proposal called the Truth in Job Advertising and Accountability Act has no congressional sponsor.
How to spot a ghost job
No single sign proves it, but several together should move a listing to the bottom of your pile.
- It has been up for more than 30 days, or keeps getting reposted. Check the posting date and search the title to see if the same ad runs on a loop.
- It is not on the company's own careers page. A real opening almost always is.
- The description is generic. No team, no manager, no start date, no salary where the law requires one.
- The company just announced layoffs or a hiring freeze. Check the news before you spend an evening on the cover letter.
- Nobody responds to a direct message. A recruiter or hiring manager for a live role usually answers something.
Stop waiting on listings
The bigger problem with ghost jobs is the time they cost. Every week spent tailoring applications for roles that were never open is a week of income you did not earn.
Apply where hiring is visible. Prioritise roles posted in the last two weeks, on the company's own site, with a named team. Ask people already inside the company whether the role is real.
Go to the buyer directly. Small businesses rarely post ghost jobs, because they rarely post jobs at all. They need bookkeeping, a website or video edits this month, and they pay by the project. The hourly rate calculator shows what to charge to match the salary you were applying for.
Build income that does not depend on an application. A service business, a skill sold to clients or a small online product earns while you search. How to get rich compares 15 routes by cost and timeline.
Ghost listings are one reason the job market feels harder than the official numbers suggest. The broken rung page covers the entry-level jobs that are disappearing for real, and the vibecession page explains why the mood and the data so often disagree. For the full then-vs-now on pay, housing and pensions, see why it is so hard to get ahead now.
Frequently asked questions
What is a ghost job?
A job listing for a role the company is not actively filling: the job does not exist, or the employer has no plan to hire soon. The Congressional Research Service found media reports of the practice from as early as 2003.
How many job postings are ghost jobs?
There is no official count. Greenhouse classifies 18-22% of jobs posted on its platform in a typical quarter as ghost jobs, and about 19% in the second quarter of 2026. In a 2024 Resume Builder survey, 40% of companies said they had posted a fake listing that year.
Are ghost jobs illegal?
In Ontario, employers with 25 or more staff must say in each public posting whether a vacancy exists, since 1 January 2026. New York's S8877, which would fine large employers $2,500, passed both houses. Bills have also been filed in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, California and Kentucky.
How can you tell if a job posting is a ghost job?
Warning signs include a listing open more than 30 days or reposted repeatedly, no matching ad on the company's own careers page, a generic description with no team or start date, recent layoffs or a hiring freeze, and no reply to a direct message.
Sources & References
Primary sources for the figures on this page. Where a number is not covered below, it is an estimate rather than a measurement and is labelled as such in the text.
- Ghost Jobs (In Focus IF12977) - Congressional Research Service
Definition, history and why JOLTS openings are unlikely to be ghost jobs - Senate Bill S8877 - New York State Senate
Labels for postings that are not for a current vacancy - Job Openings and Labor Turnover, September 2026 - Bureau of Labor Statistics
7.5 million openings and 5.4 million hires - Requirements related to publicly advertised job postings - Government of Ontario
Postings must say whether a vacancy exists, from 1 January 2026 - 2024 State of Job Hunting Report - Greenhouse
18-22% of jobs on its platform classified as ghost jobs each quarter - 3 in 10 companies currently have fake job postings listed - Resume Builder
40% of companies posted a fake listing in 2024 - Job seekers beware of ghost jobs - Clarify Capital
68% of managers had postings open more than 30 days
Further reading: Ghost job ads are getting so bad that lawmakers want to ban them · Ghost job ads are the latest employer tactic targeted by state lawmakers · Regulations and statutes in force as of January 1, 2026
Related Guides
- How to Get Rich: 15 Strategies With Real Data
- Best Side Hustle Ideas 2026: 30 Ranked
- Make Money From Home: 25 Proven Methods
Explore Related Tactics
Dive deeper into the specific strategies mentioned in this article:
- Ultimate Guide to AI Automation Agency
- Ultimate Guide to UGC Creator
- Ultimate Guide to Freelance Writing
- Ultimate Guide to Dropshipping 2.0
Free Tools
Browse by Category
- AI & Automation Side Hustles
- E-commerce Side Hustles
- Freelancing Side Hustles
- Content Creation Side Hustles
Read the full article at https://richtactic.com/blog/ghost-jobs