How Do Hutterites Make Money? Colonies, Farms and Tax
Hutterites make money as colonies, not individuals. Each colony runs a large mechanised farm producing grain, hogs, eggs, turkeys and dairy, and many add a manufacturing shop. All income goes to a common purse. Members draw no wages and own no property, and colonies pay income tax under communal rules.
| By RichTactic Editorial Team
Quick Answer: Hutterite colonies earn from grain, hogs, eggs, turkeys and manufacturing. Why the colony owns everything, members draw no wages, and how the tax works. This comprehensive guide (9 min read) covers verified strategies with real income data.
Hutterite colonies earn from grain, hogs, eggs, turkeys and manufacturing. Why the colony owns everything, members draw no wages, and how the tax works.
Category: Communities | Read Time: 9 min read | Published: 2026-11-14
Tags: how do hutterites make money, how do hutterite colonies make money, are hutterites rich, do hutterites pay taxes, do hutterites pay taxes in canada, do hutterites pay income tax, are hutterites tax exempt, what do hutterites do, hutterite colony, hutterite manufacturing, section 143 income tax act, 501d apostolic association
Key Takeaways
- Based on verified income data from 186 side hustle tactics and real-world case studies
- Income figures are estimates - individual results vary by market, effort, and skill level
- Most side hustles can be started with $0-$500 in startup capital
- Typical timeline to first income: 2 weeks to 3 months depending on the strategy
- The best approach combines a high-margin skill-based hustle with disciplined reinvestment
What You'll Learn
This in-depth guide covers everything you need to know about how do hutterites make money? colonies, farms and tax. Based on verified income data and real-world case studies from our database of 186 side hustle tactics.
People who search for how Hutterites make money have usually bought colony eggs or vegetables, farmed next to a colony, or grown up on one. What follows is for anyone who wants the real numbers behind the common purse.
Hutterites make money as colonies, not as individuals. Each colony runs a large mechanised farm (grain, hogs, eggs, turkeys, dairy and beef) and, more often than before, a manufacturing shop. All income goes into a common purse the colony owns. Members draw no wages and own no property, and the colony provides their housing, food, clothing and care. Colonies pay income tax under special communal rules in Canada and the US.
How do Hutterite colonies make money?
Farming first. The Hutterites' own site says that almost all Hutterites are sustained through farming, with most colonies working between 3,000 and 12,000 acres. A colony typically holds 50 to 120 people, and the mean is about 80 people in roughly 14 families. That is a lot of people for one farm to feed, so colonies farm at scale and add livestock barns that need daily labour.
The Canadian census gives the size of the whole system. In 2016 it recorded 370 Hutterite colonies in Canada with 35,010 people: 175 colonies in Alberta, 110 in Manitoba and 70 in Saskatchewan. The Canadian Encyclopedia notes that each colony operates as an independent economic unit, even though colonies cooperate. In Manitoba in 1991, Hutterites owned 1.9 per cent of the province's farmland but accounted for over 25 per cent of its laying hens, over 25 per cent of its turkeys and 35 per cent of its hogs.
South of the border, Montana has the most detailed numbers. A 2019 study by the University of Montana's Bureau of Business and Economic Research and Montana State University, commissioned by a law firm and focused on the Lehrerleut branch, found that Hutterite communities support more than 2,100 year-round jobs and over $365 million in annual spending in the state. Its breakdown of where colony revenue comes from is the clearest answer to the title question:
| Source of Hutterite production value (Montana, 2019 study) | Share |
|---|---|
| Grain | 39% |
| Hogs | 29% |
| Eggs | 13% |
| Dairy | 9% |
| Cattle | 8% |
The same study found Montana colonies produce 90 percent of the state's hogs, 95 percent of its eggs, 34 percent of its dairy, 16 percent of its poultry and 5 percent of its grain, from 53 communities with more than 5,000 members.
South Dakota has the largest Hutterite population in the US. SD News Watch reported in 2026 that the state has more than 60 colonies and that Hutterites make up about 10% of its farming population. Citing the South Dakota Poultry Industries Association, it reported that colonies are the state's top turkey producers, at an average of 5 million turkeys a year. Many colonies ship their birds to Dakota Provisions in Huron, a Hutterite-owned processing plant.
That plant is a good example of how colonies grow income beyond the farm gate. The Minneapolis Fed reported in 2006 that the Huron turkey plant was owned largely by 44 Hutterite colonies in the Dakotas and Minnesota and was due to open with about 400 non-Hutterite employees. The colonies built it after processing contracts squeezed their margins. An earlier step, a soybean feed cooperative formed in the 1980s, paid co-op dividends that an attorney for the colonies put at about $15 a ton at one point.
What do Hutterite colonies manufacture?
Hutterites.org explains why more colonies now run shops: big machinery means crops need fewer workers, and the capital cost of new land or new barns blocks farm expansion, so colonies have invested in manufacturing to supplement income.
Crystal Spring Colony near Ste. Agathe, Manitoba, shows how this usually starts. Prairie Hog Country reported that the colony began building its own barn equipment in the early 1980s because purchased equipment had awkward latches, and most of the steel in its main plant now goes into pig feeders and sow crates. When the hog industry crashed in 2009, the colony started Black Earth Grills, and about 25 per cent of the plant's work goes to grills and Infocus tool cubes. Its welding and painting site off the colony hires staff from surrounding communities. The colony, at around 200 people, farms 10,000 acres of cropland.
Other documented examples:
- Foam insulation. CR Foam, founded in 2016 on Spring Valley Colony in South Dakota, serves 11 states, according to SD News Watch. Colonies there also produce steel and prefab products.
- Metalwork and farm equipment. The Minneapolis Fed found that 10 to 12 colonies in the Dakotas and Minnesota had substantial manufacturing businesses in 2006, including metal cladding and feed mill equipment at Newdale Colony, and ground source heat pumps sold in 35 states and Canada from Millbrook Industries near Mitchell.
- Livestock equipment generally. A South Dakota Farm Bureau official told the Fed that Hutterites are "famous for getting involved in allied industries", including livestock equipment.
Are Hutterites rich?
The colony can be wealthy in land, barns and machinery. The members, individually, own nothing.
Both halves are written into law and into colony charters. Canada's Income Tax Act defines a qualifying congregation as one that does not permit any of its members to own any property in their own right and requires members to devote their working lives to the congregation. In the US, a 1999 South Dakota Supreme Court ruling quoted one colony's articles of incorporation: no member may hold any real or personal property rights individually, nor hold any property rights in the corporation's property, and members work in the colony's business "without pay, wages or salary". In return, the court noted, colonies provide food, clothing, shelter and medical care "from the cradle to the grave".
Per person, the land base is smaller than many assume. The Canadian Encyclopedia notes that each Hutterite family has less than 50 per cent of the land of a typical single-family prairie farm. In Manitoba in 1991, assuming 15 families per colony, that worked out to about 122 hectares per family against 301 hectares for the average Manitoba farm.
Donald Kraybill of the Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies at Elizabethtown College described a colony to the Minneapolis Fed as "basically a large corporate farm", with communally owned technology that gives it bargaining power. The structure looks corporate too: a minister as spiritual leader, a colony manager who handles finances and business, a farm manager who runs field work, and a council of managers.
Do Hutterites pay taxes?
Yes, in both countries, under rules written for communal groups.
Canada. Section 143 of the Income Tax Act treats a colony as a trust. Tax is payable by the trust on its taxable income, and the colony cannot deduct salaries, wages or benefits provided to members. The colony can elect to allocate its income to its participating members, who are the adults, using a formula set out in the Act. Gord Tait, a CPA at MNP who has worked with Hutterite colonies, told a Lethbridge public affairs forum that the income allotted to individuals is reported on personal tax returns and taxed at personal rates. The forum's session summary adds two disadvantages: colonies cannot allocate income to members under 18, as an ordinary farm family can pay its children, and they could not allocate income to spouses until 1997.
United States. Colonies can qualify under section 501(d) of the Internal Revenue Code, which exists for religious and apostolic associations with a common treasury. The South Dakota colony whose articles were quoted in the 1999 ruling states that it is a 501(d) corporation with a common treasury. The IRS's own guide sets out the trade: the colony itself is exempt, but members must include their pro rata share of its taxable income in their gross income as dividends, whether or not it is distributed. That share is not subject to self-employment tax. The guide cites a 1925 Hutterite case, Hutterische Bruder Gemeinde v. Commissioner, as part of the history behind the rule, which Congress added in 1936. Colonies file Form 1065, the partnership return, to report the income.
| Canada | United States | |
|---|---|---|
| Legal basis | Income Tax Act section 143 | IRC section 501(d) |
| Who pays income tax | The colony as a deemed trust, or members on income allocated to them | Members, on their share of colony income as dividends |
| Wages to members | Not deductible | None paid; income is shared pro rata |
| Self-employment tax on share | Not applicable | Not owed on the pro rata share |
Property tax is separate. The Minneapolis Fed reported that colonies pay property taxes on farmland and businesses as a family farm corporation would.
More income within your colony's rules
If you live on a colony, income decisions belong to the colony, not to you. Bring an idea to your minister and the colony manager first, and expect it to go to the council and then to the assembly of baptized men, which the Canadian Encyclopedia describes as the body that decides important matters. Women manage the kitchen, kindergarten, dry goods purchasing and vegetable production, so a garden or food idea usually starts with them.
These routes have worked for colonies and are documented above:
- Sell garden and kitchen products direct. At the Wessington Springs Farmers Market, Spring Valley Colony sells pickled vegetables at $8 a quart, plus dairy and meat products. Most states and provinces have cottage food rules for preserves and baked goods. The home bakery and cottage food guide covers how those rules usually work.
- Build what your own barns need, then sell it to neighbours. Crystal Spring started by fixing its own feeders. Farm equipment made for real barns sells to the farmers who drive past.
- Add a product that moves when your main market falls. Black Earth Grills filled the gap when feeder sales stalled in the 2009 hog crash.
- Pool with other colonies. The soybean feed co-op and the Huron turkey plant both came from colonies combining volume to get better prices or to keep the processing margin.
- Put a shop where it can hire. Crystal Spring's off-colony site hires neighbours, which keeps colony members on colony work.
Selling to the outside world
Most colony output already goes to outside buyers through ordinary channels. At Spring Valley, beef cattle go to live auctions in Mitchell and hogs go to packing plants. Turkeys go to Dakota Provisions. Crystal Spring exports feeders and crates, which its managers say softens slow domestic years. Manufactured goods that sell by quote, such as foam insulation, steel cladding or barn equipment, need someone to handle inquiries, deliveries and invoices, and the Fed found that several manufacturing colonies hired non-Hutterite salespeople for that.
For comparison: the Amish also farm and run shops, but Amish families own their own farms and businesses. The Bruderhof share a common purse like Hutterites, but the Bruderhof make their money from manufacturing, mainly school furniture and disability equipment. Mennonites, including the Low German colonies in Mexico and South America, farm on privately owned land. There is more on the differences in how close-knit communities make money.
If you have left a colony
Leaving is a money problem as much as anything else, because colony members own no property. Expect to start without savings, credit history or a work record in your own name. A few practical points:
- Your skills are worth money. Colony work covers welding, mechanics, livestock, crop work, cooking at scale and building maintenance. Employers pay for these, and many have a certification path. The list of certifications that pay well without a degree covers the trades and how long each takes.
- Get documents first. A government ID, your social insurance or social security number, and a bank account come before a paycheque.
- Finish school if you did not. The Canadian Encyclopedia notes that since the 1990s many colony students complete grade 12, and some take diploma courses off the colony in areas such as animal nutrition. If you left before grade 12, an adult high school or equivalency program opens more doors than any single job.
- Track your income for tax. Outside a colony there is no allocation formula. You are taxed on your own wages and any business income, and the side hustle tax guide covers the basics for anyone earning outside a payroll job.
In 2006, a colony president in South Dakota told the Minneapolis Fed that most young people who leave come back, which he put at 90 percent. That figure is one leader's estimate, not a survey.
Frequently asked questions
How do Hutterite colonies make money?
Mostly from large mechanised farms. A 2019 Montana study found grain made up 39 percent of Hutterite production value, hogs 29 percent, eggs 13 percent, dairy 9 percent and cattle 8 percent. A growing number of colonies also manufacture products such as hog feeders, sow crates, metal cladding and foam insulation.
Are Hutterites rich?
Colonies can hold valuable land, barns and machinery, but individual members own nothing. Canada's Income Tax Act defines a qualifying congregation as one that does not let members own property in their own right, and US colony charters bar members from holding property or drawing wages. The colony provides housing, food, clothing and care instead.
Do Hutterites pay taxes?
Yes. In Canada, section 143 of the Income Tax Act taxes a colony as a trust, and the colony can allocate income to adult members, who report it on personal returns. In the US, colonies can qualify under section 501(d), and members pay income tax on their pro rata share of colony income as dividends. Colonies also pay property tax.
Do Hutterites pay taxes in Canada?
Yes, under section 143 of the Income Tax Act. The colony is deemed a trust, cannot deduct wages or benefits paid to members, and can elect to allocate income to adult members under a set formula. A 2018 Lethbridge forum led by an MNP accountant who works with Hutterite colonies noted that colonies cannot allocate income to members under 18.
Are Hutterites tax exempt?
Not in the way most people mean. A US colony organised under section 501(d) is exempt at the colony level, but the IRS requires members to include their full pro rata share of its taxable income in their own gross income as dividends, whether or not it is paid out. In Canada the colony itself is taxed as a trust.
Do Hutterites get paid?
No. Colony members work without wages, salary or allowance, and all income goes to the common purse. One South Dakota colony's bylaws, quoted by the state's supreme court in 1999, say members work in the colony's business without pay, wages or salary. The court noted that colonies provide food, clothing, shelter and medical care from the cradle to the grave.
What do Hutterites manufacture?
Crystal Spring Colony in Manitoba builds pig feeders and sow crates and started Black Earth Grills after the 2009 hog crash. In South Dakota, Spring Valley Colony runs CR Foam, and other colonies make steel, prefab, metal cladding and feed mill equipment. Hutterites.org says colonies turned to manufacturing because land and barns cost too much to keep expanding.
Related Guides
- How to Get Rich: 15 Strategies With Real Data
- Best Side Hustle Ideas 2026: 30 Ranked
- Make Money From Home: 25 Proven Methods
Explore Related Tactics
Dive deeper into the specific strategies mentioned in this article:
- Ultimate Guide to AI Automation Agency
- Ultimate Guide to UGC Creator
- Ultimate Guide to Freelance Writing
- Ultimate Guide to Dropshipping 2.0
Free Tools
Browse by Category
- AI & Automation Side Hustles
- E-commerce Side Hustles
- Freelancing Side Hustles
- Content Creation Side Hustles
Read the full article at https://richtactic.com/blog/how-do-hutterites-make-money