How Do Mennonites Make Money? Farms, Trades and Careers
It depends on which Mennonites. Old Order and conservative Mennonites farm, run dairies, produce auctions and farm supply businesses, and work in trades, much like the Amish. Mainstream Mennonites work ordinary jobs. The church also built Everence, Ten Thousand Villages, MEDA and relief sales that raise over $4 million a year.
| By RichTactic Editorial Team
Quick Answer: Old Order Mennonites farm, run produce auctions and trades; mainstream Mennonites hold ordinary jobs. Plus Everence, Ten Thousand Villages and relief sales. This comprehensive guide (8 min read) covers verified strategies with real income data.
Old Order Mennonites farm, run produce auctions and trades; mainstream Mennonites hold ordinary jobs. Plus Everence, Ten Thousand Villages and relief sales.
Category: Communities | Read Time: 8 min read | Published: 2026-11-14
Tags: how do mennonites make money, how do mennonites get money, mennonite businesses, mennonite owned businesses, mennonite business practices, do mennonites pay taxes, do mennonite businesses pay taxes, are mennonites and amish the same, old order mennonite farming, mennonite relief sale, mennonite produce auction
Key Takeaways
- Based on verified income data from 186 side hustle tactics and real-world case studies
- Income figures are estimates - individual results vary by market, effort, and skill level
- Most side hustles can be started with $0-$500 in startup capital
- Typical timeline to first income: 2 weeks to 3 months depending on the strategy
- The best approach combines a high-margin skill-based hustle with disciplined reinvestment
What You'll Learn
This in-depth guide covers everything you need to know about how do mennonites make money? farms, trades and careers. Based on verified income data and real-world case studies from our database of 186 side hustle tactics.
Anyone looking up how Mennonites make money has usually bought something from them, a pie at a market or a quilt at an auction, or grew up Mennonite and wants the wider picture laid out plainly.
It depends on which Mennonites. Old Order and other conservative Mennonites live much like the Amish: they farm, run dairies and produce auctions, and work in trades and small shops. Mainstream Mennonites work the same jobs as their neighbours. The church also built institutions that earn and move money, including Everence, Ten Thousand Villages, MEDA and the Mennonite Central Committee relief sales.
Which Mennonites are we talking about?
"Mennonite" covers a wide spread of churches, from horse-and-buggy farmers to urban congregations. Mennonite World Conference, which keeps the global count, reports 2.03 million baptized believers in 87 countries in churches rooted in the 16th century Anabaptist movement. By region, 45% are in Africa, 29% in North America, 13% in Asia and the Pacific, 10% in Latin America and the Caribbean and 3% in Europe. About two-thirds are African, Asian or Latin American.
For money questions, the useful split is between plain and mainstream churches:
| Group | How most households earn | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Old Order and conservative Mennonites | Family farms, farm support businesses, trades and small shops, much like the Amish | Groffdale Conference ("Wenger") Mennonites, who drive horse and buggy and use tractors only on steel wheels |
| Mainstream Mennonites | Ordinary jobs, professions and businesses | Members of Mennonite Church USA and similar conferences |
A fourth group, the Low German "Old Colony" Mennonites in Mexico, Bolivia, Belize and Paraguay, has its own economy, covered separately in how Low German Mennonites make money.
How do Old Order Mennonites make money?
Mostly from family farms, and from businesses that serve those farms. The best documented example is the Groffdale Conference settlement in Yates County, New York, studied by Judson Reid of Cornell Cooperative Extension in the Journal of Amish and Plain Anabaptist Studies. His 2015 paper found that Old Order Mennonites operated 99% of the 262 dairy farms in Yates County by 2007, with an average herd of 45 cows against a state average of 109.
The same paper shows how the settlement grew income beyond milk:
| Yates County Old Order Mennonite economy (Reid, 2015) | Figure |
|---|---|
| Households in the settlement (2015) | About 578 |
| Share of Yates County dairy farms run by Old Order Mennonites (2007) | 99% |
| Finger Lakes Produce Auction sales (founded by Wenger Mennonites in 2000) | Over $3.5 million a year |
| Average yearly growth in auction sales | $185,612 |
| Agricultural support businesses run by members | About 50 |
| Farmland price in the new Malone settlement vs Yates County | $1,200-$1,500 vs $3,000-$4,000 an acre |
The support businesses include feed mills, tractor repair shops, produce growing supplies and seed distributors, and Reid notes they give jobs to members who do not farm. The produce auction works because many Mennonite growers live within delivery distance, which draws wholesale buyers from farther away each year. Family labour matters too. Reid cites research putting labour at up to 40% of variable production costs on farms outside the plain communities, while plain families have "a labor pool without a payroll". He writes that the produce auction "likely would not exist without family labor", and that greenhouses are often added as families grow.
Land cost is the pressure point. As Yates County prices rose, families began buying farms near Malone, New York, in 2009, and more young men have moved into carpentry and construction. Church members Reid interviewed saw that shift as a risk to the community's separation from the outside world, because it means working six days among non-Mennonites.
How do mainstream Mennonites make money?
The same way their neighbours do: in jobs and businesses. The Global Anabaptist Profile, a survey of Mennonite World Conference member churches led by Conrad Kanagy and published by Goshen College, found that 93 percent of North American members were at least high school graduates, and North American members were about evenly split between rural and urban homes. Asked where they stood on income in their own country, 36 percent of North American respondents placed themselves in the lower half.
What makes mainstream Mennonite economic life distinctive is less the jobs than the institutions the church built around money, work and giving.
Mennonite-founded businesses and institutions
| Institution | Founded | What it does |
|---|---|---|
| Everence (formerly Mennonite Mutual Aid) | 1945 | Faith-based banking, investing, insurance and charitable giving |
| Ten Thousand Villages | 1946 | Nonprofit fair trade retailer of artisan goods |
| MEDA (Mennonite Economic Development Associates) | Over 70 years ago, by Mennonite business leaders | Partners with entrepreneurs in farming communities to fight poverty |
| Goshen College | 1894 | Liberal arts college shaped by the Anabaptist-Mennonite tradition |
| Mennonite Central Committee relief sales | First Michiana sale 1968 | Auctions and food sales that raise money for MCC relief work |
Everence. It began as Mennonite Mutual Aid in 1945 with loans for Civilian Public Service workers returning home after World War II, became a fraternal benefit society in 1966, launched the Praxis mutual funds in 1994, and took the Everence name in 2010. In 2023, members distributed a record $104 million or more to nonprofits through Everence charitable giving accounts.
Ten Thousand Villages. In 1946, Edna Ruth Byler, a volunteer in Akron, Pennsylvania, met women in Puerto Rico's La Plata Valley who were struggling to feed their children. She paid them for their embroidery and sold it to people she knew, reinvesting the earnings to buy more. Mennonite Central Committee backed her, and the work grew into partnerships with artisan enterprises in more than 30 countries and a network of stores.
MEDA. Its own site says it was started by Mennonite business leaders called by their faith to share their knowledge and resources, and has worked in more than 80 countries.
Goshen College. The Indiana college describes itself as shaped by Anabaptist-Mennonite tradition, with about 800 students. Its official history is titled Culture for Service: A History of Goshen College, 1894-1994.
Relief sales. These are fundraisers run by volunteers, not income for the people who run them. MCC says the sales include auctions of quilts, furniture and other items and regional food such as Rollkuchen in Saskatchewan, verenika in Kansas and strawberry pie in Pennsylvania. The Michiana sale in Goshen, Indiana, has run since 1968 and is one of 30 relief sale events in the US and Canada that together raise over $4 million a year.
How Mennonite mutual aid works
Mennonite money habits show most clearly in how churches help members through hard times. Everence's own timeline records a 1979 Sharing Fund that offers financial help to people in need in partnership with local congregations, funded when members buy certain Everence products. Its stated investing principles include being "financially productive" and making "good and wise use of all the resources God has entrusted to us", alongside work for peace and care for creation.
Plain churches handle the same need without an institution. Reid describes labour exchanges as common among Old Order groups, and gives an example: a Yates County dairy barn destroyed by fire on Christmas Day 2008 was rebuilt and shipping milk again by January 2. Because members live within buggy distance, help arrives fast, which also lets families share machinery and get time-critical jobs such as silage and haymaking done on the right day.
Do Mennonites pay taxes?
Yes. Mennonites pay income, sales and property taxes like anyone else, and Mennonite businesses pay business taxes. One narrow exception exists in the US for Social Security. Members of a recognised religious group that has existed since 1950, provides for its dependent members and is conscientiously opposed to insurance can file IRS Form 4029 to apply for exemption from Social Security and Medicare taxes, giving up all Social Security benefits in return. The form's own instructions give Mennonite congregations as examples. The exemption does not cover federal income tax.
More income within your church's rules
If you belong to an Old Order or conservative church, start with your bishop or ministers and with what your church already allows. Ordnung differs from one church to the next, so a route that is fine in one district may not be in another. Routes that fit most plain churches:
- Grow for a produce auction. The Yates County example shows a wholesale auction can grow by more than $185,000 a year when enough families supply it. If your area has one, ask growers already selling there what sells and at what volume.
- Serve other farms. Feed, seed, repairs and growing supplies are businesses that serve your own community first and need no outside marketing.
- Bake or preserve for sale. Home-made food sales are governed by state cottage food rules, which differ a great deal. The home bakery and cottage food guide covers how those rules usually work.
- Learn a building trade. Carpentry and construction are where Reid found young Wenger men moving when land got expensive. If your church is wary of long weeks off the farm, a family crew working for local customers keeps more of the work among church members.
If you belong to a mainstream church, nothing in church rules limits ordinary side income. Mennonite teaching on money tends to show up in what you do with it: Everence's "stewardship investing" approach and its charitable giving accounts exist for members who want their savings and giving to match their faith. Report any side income for tax, and the side hustle tax guide covers the basics.
Selling to the outside world
Plain Mennonite families mostly sell through channels that do not need them to advertise: produce auctions where wholesale buyers bid, roadside stands, farmers markets, and orders from neighbours. Where a church allows it, one setup is selling online through a family member or partner outside the church who handles the website and shipping. The rules and the setups that work are in how Old Order communities sell online.
For comparison, the Amish rely on the same farms, shops and auctions, while Hutterites and the Bruderhof hold all income in a common purse rather than as families. The wider comparison is in how close-knit communities make money.
If you have left a plain Mennonite church
Leaving an Old Order or conservative church changes your work options more than your skills. Dairy, produce growing, carpentry, construction and mechanical repair all pay outside the church.
Practical first steps:
- Get documents in order. A state ID, your Social Security number and a bank account come before most jobs. If you were covered by a Form 4029 exemption, the form requires you to notify the IRS when you are no longer a member, and Social Security and Medicare taxes then apply to your earnings.
- Finish schooling if you need to. If your formal schooling stopped before high school, a high school equivalency test opens apprenticeships and community college.
- Use the trade you have. Construction and farm work are hiring paths that do not need a degree. The list of certifications that pay well without a degree shows which trade credentials pay most for the time they take.
Nothing here is advice to leave. It is for people who already have.
Frequently asked questions
How do Mennonites make money?
It depends on the church. Old Order and conservative Mennonites mostly farm, run farm support businesses and work in trades, much like the Amish. In Yates County, New York, Old Order Mennonites ran 99 percent of the county's 262 dairy farms in 2007. Mainstream Mennonites work ordinary jobs and run ordinary businesses.
Do Mennonites pay taxes?
Yes. Mennonites pay income, sales and property taxes like anyone else. In the US, members of a recognised religious group that has existed since 1950 and opposes insurance can file IRS Form 4029 for exemption from Social Security and Medicare taxes, giving up those benefits. The exemption never covers federal income tax.
Do Mennonite businesses pay taxes?
Yes. A Mennonite-owned business pays the same business, sales and income taxes as any other. The religious exemption that most often matters for plain Mennonite businesses is Form 4029, which can exempt qualifying members, and employers with the same exemption, from Social Security and Medicare taxes, not income tax.
Are Mennonites and Amish the same?
No, though both are Anabaptist. Old Order Mennonites earn much like the Amish, from family farms and trades, and some, such as the Groffdale Conference, also drive horse and buggy. Mainstream Mennonite churches belong to a global family of 2.03 million baptized Anabaptists in 87 countries, and their members mostly work ordinary jobs.
What businesses did Mennonites start?
Mennonites founded Everence in 1945 as Mennonite Mutual Aid, now a faith-based financial services group. Ten Thousand Villages began in 1946 when volunteer Edna Ruth Byler sold embroidery from Puerto Rico. MEDA was started by Mennonite business leaders, and Old Order Mennonites in New York founded the Finger Lakes Produce Auction in 2000.
How much do Mennonite relief sales raise?
Mennonite Central Committee lists the Michiana sale in Indiana as one of 30 relief sale events in the US and Canada that together raise over $4 million a year. Sales include auctions of quilts and furniture plus regional food, and the money funds MCC relief, development and peace work.
Related Guides
- How to Get Rich: 15 Strategies With Real Data
- Best Side Hustle Ideas 2026: 30 Ranked
- Make Money From Home: 25 Proven Methods
Explore Related Tactics
Dive deeper into the specific strategies mentioned in this article:
- Ultimate Guide to AI Automation Agency
- Ultimate Guide to UGC Creator
- Ultimate Guide to Freelance Writing
- Ultimate Guide to Dropshipping 2.0
Free Tools
Browse by Category
- AI & Automation Side Hustles
- E-commerce Side Hustles
- Freelancing Side Hustles
- Content Creation Side Hustles
Read the full article at https://richtactic.com/blog/how-do-mennonites-make-money