Leaving the Amish: How to Make a Living After You Leave
Start with documents: a birth certificate or delayed birth record, a Social Security number applied for in person, and a state ID or driver's license. Then earn a GED or HiSET. Trades that hire on skill pay well without a degree: carpenters earned a median $29.12 an hour in May 2025.
| By RichTactic Editorial Team
Quick Answer: Leaving the Amish with an eighth-grade education: birth certificate, Social Security number, GED, trades that hire on skill, and the groups that help. This comprehensive guide (7 min read) covers verified strategies with real income data.
Leaving the Amish with an eighth-grade education: birth certificate, Social Security number, GED, trades that hire on skill, and the groups that help.
Category: Communities | Read Time: 7 min read | Published: 2026-11-14
Tags: leaving the amish, leaving the amish community, what happens when you leave the amish, what happens if you leave the amish, can you leave the amish, ex amish, ex amish jobs, ex amish metal roofing, how do you become ex amish, amish no social security number, amish birth certificate, ged after leaving the amish
Key Takeaways
- Based on verified income data from 186 side hustle tactics and real-world case studies
- Income figures are estimates - individual results vary by market, effort, and skill level
- Most side hustles can be started with $0-$500 in startup capital
- Typical timeline to first income: 2 weeks to 3 months depending on the strategy
- The best approach combines a high-margin skill-based hustle with disciplined reinvestment
What You'll Learn
This in-depth guide covers everything you need to know about leaving the amish: how to make a living after you leave. Based on verified income data and real-world case studies from our database of 186 side hustle tactics.
You already did the hard part: deciding to build a life outside the church you grew up in. This page is for people ready to sort out papers, a school credential and the first paying work.
To make a living after leaving the Amish, get your documents first (a birth certificate or delayed birth record, a Social Security number applied for in person, and a state ID or driver's license), then a GED or HiSET. Trades that hire on skill pay well without a degree: carpenters earned a median $29.12 an hour and roofers $26.65 in May 2025.
What you bring with you
More than it might feel like. Most Amish youth learn a trade by working beside adults. Kraybill describes the system as apprenticeship, the training model most of mainstream America abandoned: he once watched a 13-year-old repair hydraulic machinery after years in his father's shop. Carpentry, roofing, framing, furniture making, small engine repair, farm work, baking, sewing and running a market stand are all skills employers and customers pay for.
What you probably lack is paper: a diploma, sometimes a birth certificate or Social Security number, a driver's license, a credit history. Those are fixable, and the order you fix them in matters.
Your standing with your family depends on whether you were baptized. The Young Center at Elizabethtown College explains that people who leave without being baptized are not excommunicated or shunned, because they never made baptismal vows. Baptized members who leave may face shunning, which varies by affiliation, family and church. About 85 percent of Amish youth eventually join the church, so those who leave are a minority.
Who leaves, and where they land
Ideastream Public Media, reporting from Ohio, found that people who leave are typically around 18 years old and have limited resources. In their study of the Holmes County settlement, Charles Hurst and David McConnell identify two main reasons people leave, as summarised by Amish America: "the desire for fewer lifestyle restrictions" and "the desire for a more intense religious experience."
Former members tend to cluster where they find cultural familiarity and practical support, and an ex-Amish community in Columbia, Missouri, featured in a National Geographic special, is one example. Living near other former Amish can mean a first job, a ride to work and someone who already knows the paperwork.
Step 1: get your documents in order
Work through these in order, because each one is used to get the next.
Birth certificate
If you were born in a hospital or with a licensed midwife, a birth record probably exists, and you can order a certified copy from the birth records office (usually the state health department) of the state where you were born. If you were born at home without a licensed attendant, there may be no record.
Pennsylvania's process is typical. If the Department of Health issues a "Certificate of No Birth Record," a person over age 7 with documentary proof of a Pennsylvania birth can file a Delayed Report of Live Birth. There is no fee. The information on your evidence (church records, school records, a family Bible, a doctor's record) must match the report. Other states have similar procedures through their health departments.
Social Security number
Some Amish adults already have one: anyone who applied for the religious exemption on IRS Form 4029 needed a number to file it. If you never had one, the number and card are free from the Social Security Administration.
For an adult born in the US, the SSA's document list sets out what you need:
- Citizenship: a US birth certificate or US passport.
- Age: your birth certificate. If none exists, the SSA may accept a religious record made before age five showing your date of birth, or a US hospital birth record.
- Identity: a current driver's license, state non-driver ID or passport. If you have none, the SSA may accept other current documents such as an employee or school ID.
- An in-person interview. Anyone age 12 or older applying for an original number must appear in person, and the SSA may ask about the schools you attended or for tax records to confirm you were never assigned a number.
Bring originals or copies certified by the issuing agency. The SSA does not accept photocopies or notarized copies.
State ID and driver's license
Your state motor vehicle office issues non-driver IDs and learner's permits; its document list usually builds on the birth certificate and Social Security number above. A driver's license matters more than it might seem, because construction crews work at changing job sites.
If you had a Social Security exemption
If you were a church member with an approved Form 4029, the exemption ends when you leave. The form itself commits you to notify the IRS within 60 days of no longer being a member or following the group's teachings, by letter to the IRS center in Philadelphia. After that, Social Security and Medicare tax applies to your wages and self-employment income like anyone else's, and you start building toward benefits.
Step 2: GED or HiSET
A high school equivalency credential opens most jobs that ask for a diploma, community college and apprenticeship programs. The GED has four separate tests that you can take one at a time: Mathematical Reasoning (115 minutes), Reasoning Through Language Arts (150 minutes, including a 45-minute essay), Social Studies (70 minutes) and Science (90 minutes). The price varies by state.
Some states use or also offer the HiSET exam, which can be taken at a test centre or at home, with requirements and fees set state by state. Your state's adult education office will tell you which test it uses and where prep classes are.
One former member who passed hers with help from Mission to Amish People put the case simply: "There's a lot of jobs where you don't need a college education, but you do need a GED."
Science may need the most study. Amish schools teach reading, arithmetic, spelling, grammar, penmanship, history and some geography, but the Young Center notes that science is not usually taught.
Step 3: work that hires on skill
The fastest income usually comes from the trades you already know. Bureau of Labor Statistics data for May 2025:
| Job | Median pay | Credential needed to start | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carpenter | $29.12/hour ($60,580/year) | High school diploma or equivalent; apprenticeship | BLS |
| Roofer | $26.65/hour ($55,440/year) | No formal credential; on-the-job training | BLS |
| Heavy truck driver | $28.19/hour ($58,640/year) | Commercial driver's license (CDL) | BLS |
Construction is often the first job for men who leave. Joe Keim, who left the Amish himself and founded Mission to Amish People, told Ideastream that former Amish who own construction companies regularly hire men coming out, and that the jobs pay well. He added that women have fewer equivalent openings: some women run bakeries and small home businesses, but they cannot offer the young women coming out what construction offers the men.
Roofing projects 12,000 openings a year over the decade to 2035 and needs no diploma, which makes it a well-paid job you can start before your GED. Carpentry asks for a diploma or equivalent, so the GED matters more there.
Truck driving takes longer to set up. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration requires you to hold a commercial learner's permit for 14 days and complete entry-level driver training before the CDL skills test, which has three parts. To drive across state lines you must be at least 21.
For women leaving, the skills many already have (baking, cleaning, sewing, managing a stand) map onto jobs and small businesses. Mission to Amish People trains young women in retail at its own store, and one former member profiled by Ideastream passed her GED and moved on to a factory job through a temp agency. A house cleaning business needs little money to start; one young Amish woman in Karen Johnson-Weiner's research built a cleaning business serving three car dealerships while still in the church. Certifications that raise pay without a degree are listed in certifications that pay well without a degree.
Step 4: organisations that help
Each of these was checked as operating in November 2026. They differ in approach, so read their own sites.
| Organisation | What it is | What it offers |
|---|---|---|
| Mission to Amish People (Greenwich, Ohio) | Christian ministry run by former Amish Joe and Esther Keim, founded in 2000 per its site; its stated purpose includes evangelizing Amish and former Amish | Short-term housing and transport, help applying for birth certificates and Social Security numbers, job applications, driving lessons, computer classes, GED and college help; New Beginnings Homestead housing for young women |
| Amish Heritage Foundation | Secular nonprofit founded in 2018 | Education past eighth grade, help getting documented, counselling and support for women inside and outside the church, virtual speaker series |
| SpringHaven Counseling Center (Mt. Eaton office in Dundee, Ohio, plus a Fountain office) | Nonprofit counselling centre with Christian staff, serving Holmes and Wayne counties and people of all faiths | Mental health counselling; Ideastream reported that 40 percent of its clients are Amish or Plain, and that its purpose is not to influence anyone to stay or leave |
Mission to Amish People also runs a Former Amish Reunion, held in Orrville, Ohio, in July 2026. The Amish Heritage Foundation's founder, Torah Bontrager, told Ideastream in 2023 that it had helped more than 1,000 women.
Leaving is a large life change, and SpringHaven's clinical director told Ideastream that a stressor of that size can make existing anxiety or depression worse. Counselling is worth arranging early, not only in a crisis. SpringHaven lists a sliding scale fee for those who qualify.
Money basics in your first year
- Open a bank account once you have ID and a Social Security number. Direct deposit is safer than carrying cash.
- Expect tax withholding. As an employee, income tax plus Social Security and Medicare tax come out of each paycheck. If you take side jobs, set money aside: our side hustle tax guide covers self-employment tax.
- Price your own work. Furniture, cabinet work and baking you did for the family business are things outsiders pay for. Start with people who already know your work.
If you want to keep a foot in both worlds
Some people raised in or near the community build work that serves it, as drivers, suppliers or partners who handle the phone and internet side. That role is described on our page on how Old Order communities sell online. The economic picture you are leaving is on how the Amish make money.
People leaving other closed communities face the same paperwork and schooling gaps; see leaving ultra-Orthodox Judaism: how to make a living. Other communities are compared in how close-knit communities make money.
Frequently asked questions
What happens when you leave the Amish?
It depends on whether you were baptized. The Young Center at Elizabethtown College explains that people who leave without being baptized are not excommunicated or shunned, because they never made baptismal vows. Baptized members who leave may be shunned, and the practice varies by affiliation, family and church. Practically, most people who leave need documents, a GED and a first job.
Can you leave the Amish?
Yes. The Young Center states that Amish people are free to join and leave the community, and that baptism is a voluntary adult decision, usually made between 18 and 21. About 85 percent of Amish youth eventually join the church. Those who leave are usually young: Ideastream Public Media reported that most are around 18.
Do Amish have social security numbers?
Many do, because IRS Form 4029, the religious exemption from Social Security tax, requires one. Some, especially those born at home, never got one. An adult applying for a first number must apply in person with proof of citizenship and age, such as a birth certificate, and the Social Security Administration may accept a religious record made before age five if no birth certificate exists.
What jobs do ex Amish get?
Construction, roofing, carpentry and furniture work are common first jobs, because the skills transfer directly. The BLS put median pay at $29.12 an hour for carpenters and $26.65 for roofers in May 2025, and roofing needs no formal credential. Joe Keim of Mission to Amish People says former Amish construction owners regularly hire men who leave.
How do ex Amish get a GED?
Through a state adult education program or test centre. The GED has four tests that can be taken separately: math, language arts with a 45-minute essay, social studies and science, with prices set by state. Some states use the HiSET instead. Mission to Amish People in Ohio helps people who leave prepare for the GED.
Where can ex Amish get help?
Mission to Amish People in Greenwich, Ohio, a Christian ministry run by former Amish, helps with housing, birth certificates, Social Security numbers, jobs, driving and the GED. The Amish Heritage Foundation, a secular nonprofit, focuses on education and getting documented. SpringHaven Counseling Center in Dundee, Ohio, offers counselling with a sliding scale for those who qualify.
Related Guides
- How to Get Rich: 15 Strategies With Real Data
- Best Side Hustle Ideas 2026: 30 Ranked
- Make Money From Home: 25 Proven Methods
Explore Related Tactics
Dive deeper into the specific strategies mentioned in this article:
- Ultimate Guide to AI Automation Agency
- Ultimate Guide to UGC Creator
- Ultimate Guide to Freelance Writing
- Ultimate Guide to Dropshipping 2.0
Free Tools
Browse by Category
- AI & Automation Side Hustles
- E-commerce Side Hustles
- Freelancing Side Hustles
- Content Creation Side Hustles
Read the full article at https://richtactic.com/blog/leaving-the-amish-how-to-make-a-living